Budget Hero

Budget Hero title screenYou’re probably familiar with Marketplace on NPR, but did you know that they make games now too? They recently published an online “watercooler game” called Budget Hero. It’s pretty basic and is currently pretty slow since their server is getting hammered, but it’s worth a look. Balancing the federal budget has never been so interesting!

When you start the game, you get to pick three goals, which is a nice way of reminding you that there’s no objectively best federal budget. The best you can do is to have a budget that is the best at a particular category. Once that’s done, you get a bunch of dials at the bottom that tell you how your budget looks in terms of long-term sustainability, current deficit, and your goals. Above that are buildings that represent different budget categories, the taller the more expensive. It’s an amazing way of visualizing the budget. I had no idea how little a portion of the budget goes to education, especially versus the big three: defense (and diplomacy), healthcare, and social security. Clicking on a building gives you a selection of “cards” that describe a budget change (“reduce military spending by 10%”) and a cost or benefit (“-$305 billion”). Double-clicking gives you more information on the pros and cons of that particular card. You can also modify taxes in a similar way.

Playing around with it was really interesting. Although I’ve heard about things like Bush’s tax cuts, it’s hard to put it all in perspective. In Budget Hero, I can put it in terms that I understand (if I repeal Bush’s tax cuts, I can fund mandatory healthcare and alternative energy research).

There are some drawbacks too. Clicking on a building (budget topic) can sometimes give you a “server is busy” error message. The cards also focus on specific policy directions that have been talked about. If you want to do something off the wall, you won’t be able to model that here.

Despite these minor flaws, it’s entertaining and a great way to make sense of the budget. It also helped me get a handle on the costs of some of the issues I feel passionate about and what I’d have to sacrifice to pay for them.

I highly recommend trying it out!

  del.icio.us this!

2 Responses so far »

  1. 1

    arduous said,

    June 3, 2008 @ 3:34 am

    Oh geez, now I know what I’m going to be spending all my free time playing!!

    Sigh. I’m a nerd.

  2. 2

    Srini Radhakrishna said,

    June 4, 2008 @ 4:30 pm

    I was part of the team at American Public Media that produced Budget Hero, and have enjoyed reading the spirited discussion and debate that the game has sparked. We hoped the game would get people talking about the federal budget, and it appears on that score it’s been a success.

    We’ve also been monitoring comments to find suggestions for improving the game, ideas for new policy options, or to spot technical problems.

    Based on the feedback that we’ve received here and elsewhere, we’ve added several new policy options to the game:

    End No Child Left Behind (Schools & Learning)
    Increase NSF grants by 50 percent (Science & Nature)
    Cut NSF grants by 50 percent (Science & Nature)
    Double funds for alternative energy (Science & Nature)
    Ground the space program (Science & Nature)
    Stop exploring Earth from space (Science & Nature)
    Increase NASA funds by 50 percent (Science & Nature)

    Sorry, but you’ll need to play the game again to see how much each of these spends or saves!

    We’ll be adding more options to the game as new policy proposals crop up during the campaign season. If you have any other ideas for cards we should add, or any further suggestions or feedback, please send them to me at budgethero@mpr.org.

    Srini Radhakrishna

Comment RSS · TrackBack URI

Speak your piece